Last Updated on

Best Styptic Pencil

Shaving cuts can’t be avoided all the time, and you need to have styptic pencils to handle the situation. So, find the best styptic pencils here!

A styptic pencil is nothing but a stick of alum that serves only one purpose for wet shavers.

And that is to ensure that if you cut yourself during shaving and aren’t able to stop the bleeding. Then, applying a styptic pencil to the cut will stop the bleeding, and you can carry on with your work. 

While the implementation & purpose of the styptic pencil is very simple, finding the best styptic pencil for yourself isn’t. 

Don’t worry, because, in this article, we will go through the best styptic pencils available in the market, their benefits & issues, along with a guide & a few tips on how to find the right styptic pencil for yourself.

5 Best Styptic Pencil in 2022

Omega Potassium Alum Stick

Best Overall

If you're looking for the best of the best, then there are only a handful of styptic pencil that comes closer to what the Omega Potassium Alum stick can provide. From performance to design, this product has it all.

Type Traditional
Material Potassium Alum
Item Form Stick
Size 2 oz

If you have sensitive skin or looking for a styptic pencil and deodorant combo, then this styptic pencil is just for you. This potassium-made alum stick ensures that your skin remains healthy and comfortable after each shave.

It closes up cuts and pores at ease without causing any irritation. But don’t get this one too wet, as it will become a bit too slick for you to handle. And as it is made from natural potassium alum, you don’t have to worry about additives or chemicals.

Product Pros

  • Has ingredients that tighten up the skin
  • It can be used as an unscented deodorant.
  • Helps relieve irritation and make your skin feel comfortable
  • Bill perfectly for a reasonable price

Product Cons

  • Quite slick when wet
  • Difficult to grip
  • Doesn't stay attached to the base
  • The surface doesn't remain smooth and scratches the skin a bit

Clubman Pinaud Styptic Pencil

Best Value

For the best value in the market, the Clubman Pinaud styptic pencil is the best choice with good performance. It offers quality and a good budget all at the same time.

Type Traditional
Material Aluminum Sulfate & Titanium Di-Oxide
Item Form Stick
Size 0.33 oz

If you are on a budget and want the best value-for-money styptic pencil on the market, then there is a competition for this styptic pencil from Clubman.

You receive three packs of this aluminum sulfate & titanium dioxide-based styptic pencil, and we can ensure that it will instantly stop your bleeding from knicks.

And it just doesn’t stop with cuts in the face. This styptic pencil can also treat small cuts on arms, legs, and so on. Just make sure to get them properly wet before using them.

Product Pros

  • Work equally well on small cuts
  • Secured packaging ensures no damage to the pencils
  • Extremely handy & easy to use
  • The pencil stops the bleeding immediately

Product Cons

  • It burns
  • Too small to last
  • Some of them are just flat out 
  • Hard consistency may not be easy to spread evenly

Infa-Lab MAGIC TOUCH Liquid Styptic

Best Travel

If you are looking for an on-the-go liquid styptic pencil, then the Magic Touch will do wonders for you and your shaving experience.

Type Liquid
Material Benzalkonium Chloride, Aloe Vera
Item Form Dropper
Size 0.5 oz

This dropper-based liquid styptic pencil is quite good for the price it costs. It is a budget-friendly styptic pencil that works to prevent bleeding as soon as it is applied to the skin.

It is best for facial bleeding as the tip of the dropper is adjustable regarding the amount of liquid that is falling from it. And on the plus side, this styptic pencil doesn’t sting at all.

So, if you are afraid of the burn and have sensitive skin, then this is the one for you.

Product Pros

  • Stops the bleeding immediately
  • Designed well for facial bleeding
  • Does not sting when used
  • Great for travel because the bottle doesn't leak at all

Product Cons

  • Wounds sometimes darken more
  • Take longer overall to seal up the wound
  • Not as effective as a styptic pencil
  • The active ingredient is too low to cause effective clotting

Pacific Shaving Company Nick Stick Styptic Pencil

Best Quality

This product offers great quality but at the same time costs quite a bit compared to its competitors. That being said, the overall performance out lifts the cost it comes with. 

Type Liquid
Material Ethyl Alcohol, Aloe Vera, Vitamin E 
Item Form Stick
Size 0.25 oz

This liquid styptic pencil has it all, from safe and natural ingredients to a burn or stingless experience; this styptic pencil covers all of them. You don’t even need to clean up with tissue paper as the residue dissolves afterward.

What’s more, you can take it anywhere you want without worrying about it losing its effectiveness. The strength is also admirable as it can close almost any type of bleeding your face might encounter during shaving.

But the cost is a bit high but at the same time so are the benefits!

Product Pros

  • The Roll-on applicator is easy to apply
  • Styptic pencil causes minimal or no pain
  • Great for facial nicks
  • Stops bleeding with no white crusties

Product Cons

  • Had to apply this product multiple times
  • Expensive
  • Leaves a sting

BarberUpp Green Stix + Styptic Pencil Set 

Best Usability

For the best usability, only a few can match the stats that these products from BarberUpp provide. They are a great value-for-money option and a must-buy if you are on a budget.

Type Traditional
Material Aluminum Sulfate
Item Form Stick
Size 1.76 oz

This is a standard traditional styptic pencil that offers what styptic pencil stands for. It closes the bleeding during shaving. That’s it. There is no fancy after effects or anything, and completely scentless.

But they come in a good number, and the price is decent. So, if you just want the traditional experience of the styptic pencil, then this is the one you are looking for.

Product Pros

  • Scentless styptic pencil, perfect for people with a sensitive nose
  • Easy to use as it works instantly
  • Works for both men and women
  • Provides value for money

Product Cons

  • May break into pieces after use
  • Left sand-like granules
  • Brittle at times
  • Ineffective at stopping bleeding from small nicks

OSMA Styptic stick

Best Clean Up

If you like a minimalistic lifestyle, then you will love the styptic pencil from OSMA. It is small, effective, and one of the best clean-up styptic pencils there is.

Type Traditional
Material Potassium Alum
Item Form Stick
Size 0.4 oz

This product from OSMA is quite small, but that makes it one of the best choices to take on travels. As it is also a traditional styptic pencil, you don’t have to worry about its effectiveness because it can heal nicks & cuts in a few seconds.

It is also very easy to clean up after with this styptic pencil and is made of completely natural materials. And that is why it is beloved by many and selected as their go-to after-shave product.

Product Pros

  • Very easy to carry during travels 
  • Heals nicks almost instantly
  • Easy to clean up
  • No more dabbing required

Product Cons

  • Material is not as compact/dense
  • Stick is quite crumbly
  • Draws moisture
  • Rough consistency

My Nik Is Sealed Roll-On Liquid Styptic

Best Performance

As the name suggests, this product is one of the best nick sealers in the business. While the price may seem high at first sight, it is pale to the performance comparison.

Type Liquid
Material Vitamin E & Aloe Extract 
Item Form Roll-on
Size 0.4 oz

This product is as close to a complete natural liquid styptic pencil as it gets. This is a roll-on version of liquid styptic pencil, making it extremely easy to move around in your face without hurting the cut spots.

It also works as a scrub as the aloe vera works to smoothen the skin and makes it lighter and healthier. The vitamin E also ensures that your skin gets tight naturally and starts sealing the blood off effectively.

So, even if the price is a bit high, this product is arguably one of the best styptic pencils out there in the current market.

Product Pros

  • Neat packaging ensures the pencils are protected
  • Good for travel
  • Stops bleeding within seconds
  • Generates no mess, so easy to clean up

Product Cons

  • Over-priced
  • Over-priced
  • Hard to find product
  • Does not last long

What to Consider When Choosing Styptic Pencils for Yourself

There are quite a few things that you will have to consider when you are looking for the best styptic pencil for yourself. Because while a styptic pencil can be the best choice for someone, it might just be the worst choice for yourself. 

Type of Styptic Pencil

The first thing that you need to consider is which type of styptic pencil you will be going for. There are some variants out there, but all of them can be divided into three types:

  • Traditional Styptic Pencils
  • Liquid Styptic Pencils
  • Styptic Pencil Powder Packs

Traditional Styptic Pencils

By traditional, we mean the styptic pencils that have been in use since 1930.

When you imagine a styptic pencil, this is the one you are thinking of. To be more precise, the traditional styptic pencil is a pencil-like stick of alum or styptic agents with similar characteristics, which is used to close up any cut during a shave. 

Most traditional styptic pencils are budget friendly but can be irritating to people with sensitive skin. That being said, you just can’t go wrong with traditional styptic pencils because they are a classic in the shaving community. 

The benefits that you can enjoy with this type of styptic pencil are:

  • Comes with a high strength stat regarding aluminum sulfate
  • They are budget-friendly
  • Fast application process
  • It saves time; no need to take any fancy steps to get the work done
  • Found in almost every local shop & drug store
  • Very easy to store

The issues that you might run into with traditional styptic pencils are:

  • Can cause skin irritation
  • Getting the pencil tip wet can be a challenge for beginners & first-time users
  • It can sting a bit more compared to other styptic pencil types

Liquid Styptic Pencil

As the name suggests, liquid styptic pencils are nothing more than traditional styptic pencils just liquified. While that is true, there are some improvements added on to make it a bit more desirable than the competition.

The original ingredients remain the same; aluminum sulfate or alum will be the center. But other add-ons like vitamins, menthols, and other ingredients might add a bit of aroma to the mix. 

What this does is that it makes the liquid styptic pencil more desirable than the solid traditional styptic pencil. Because you generally don’t get any flavor or aroma from the general styptic pencil. 

Also, as it is in liquid form and sealed airtight, they have higher longevity and better bacteria & virus resistance than others. But this is a very small advantage over other types of styptic pencil that is hardly noticeable.

Advantages: 

The advantages that you will be able to have with liquid styptic pencil are:

  • There is more than one way you can apply them on your cut skin: you can use a roller or directly apply them
  • Every application process is simple & easy; the end goal is just to put the liquid on the cut spot
  • Comes with a cooling effect that is comfortable even for sensitive skins
  • Offers a variety of aroma and color options to choose
  • Tends to have a better healing rate compared to both traditional styptic pencils and styptic powder packs
  • No need to use water with the styptic pencil
  • Some liquid styptic pencil acts as a scrub as well

Disadvantages:

The disadvantages that you have to face by using liquid styptic pencil are:

  • They aren’t common in local shops & drug stores; online is the best and sometimes the only option to get them
  • Price is variable; some are budget-friendly while some are not
  • If left in the open, then liquid styptic pencil can lose its effectiveness drastically
  • There is always the risk of spilling and leaking
  • Not best for traveling
  • It isn’t as powerful as a traditional styptic pencil

Styptic Pencil Powder Packs

This is just a powdered version of the standard styptic pencil. There is nothing more to it. But some styptic powder packs may come with a bit of fragrance, but that’s all. You get no added benefit with these except for the fact of convenience.

The small packs are easy to carry and don’t stick out as the traditional styptic pencils do. And also, you don’t have to worry about sealants or keeping the styptic pencil in an airtight situation as the packs don’t carry much powder anyway. 

With these styptic pencil powder packs, you will enjoy the following benefits:

  • Best for traveling shaving kits
  • Budget-friendly pricing
  • Some powders come with fragrance 

The issues that you have to face with these powder packs are:

  • Don’t offer many features over a standard styptic pencil
  • The application process is a bit too long and complicated compared to others
  • Not an on-the-go solution for shave cuts
  • It can be quite irritating for people with sensitive skin

Strength of The Styptic Pencil

While almost all types of styptic pencil offer a standard strength, you can get ones that offer a higher or lower strength based on your skin preference. 

Now, this is something you will figure out after using a styptic pencil for a while. If it burns or stings too much when you use it, you might have to modify the strength of the styptic pencil you are using.

While that’s true, if you already have sensitive skin, then starting with mild strength isn’t a bad option. 

Do keep in mind that while it may sting a bit, a high strength will ensure that the effects of the styptic pencil take faster to administer.

But, to be honest, the difference isn’t that much. So, if you have sensitive skin, you can either go with the standard strength or lower it down slightly.

You can determine the strength of the amount of aluminum sulfate in the styptic pencil. But if you have allergies or reactions to other chemicals, you should also check their strength on the styptic pencil.

Now, if you are still concerned over the strength or don’t know how your skin will react, then the safest way is to go with a liquid styptic pencil. They have a lower strength compared to the standard styptic pencil, but the effectiveness difference isn’t that much.

So, why not just play it safe?

The Durability of The Styptic Pencil 

This factor is only concerned if you are going with a standard styptic pencil. That being said, the liquid styptic pencil should also offer decent durability.

For traditional or standard styptic pencil, you should look for a durable pencil that is not completely stiff. It should be able to bend just a little if the need arises, that’s all.

On the other hand, the durability shouldn’t drop significantly once the pencil touches water. This is because there will be times when you accidentally put a bit of water upon it.

Would you like it if the styptic pencil started melting down upon coming in contact with water? So, look for one that can take a bit of a hit without being too stiff.

Condition of The Container for The Liquid Styptic Pencil

As mentioned earlier, liquid styptic pencils come with either a dropper that allows you to drop the antiseptic on the cut or a simple container from where you have to apply the solution.

Now, if it comes with a dropper, then the first thing that you need to check is how strong the dropper is and what it is made of. 

On the other hand, if the liquid styptic pencil comes in a container (which is very rare), you have to determine the durability of the container and if there is any chance of leaking. 

Size & Amount

The final factor you need to consider is the overall size and the amount of styptic pencil you will be getting for yourself. 

Do keep in mind that you won’t need a lot of styptic pencil unless you cut yourself a lot during shaving. If that is not the case, then picking a medium-sized pencil would be the best option. 

On the other hand, if you feel that you need a bigger size or you are just starting out wet shave, then going bigger is the better choice. 

You should also consider whether you will be taking the styptic pencil anywhere if you are planning to shave during your travels. If that is the case, then medium to small size styptic pencil will be our recommendation. 

Tips for Buying And Using Styptic Pencils

While you have to watch out for certain factors when purchasing your styptic pencils, there are a few tips that you can use when buying & using them for yourself. And these are:

  1. Don’t buy a big-sized styptic pencil in the first place; start with small because you won’t need as much as you think you will. 
  2. The pencil shouldn’t be too sharp. Yes, over time, the sharp edge will go flat & dull, but when you are sharpening it again, don’t make it extremely pointy.
    Otherwise, you will end up hurting yourself when you are applying it to your cut skin.
  3. Also, don’t overuse it. Adding too much styptic pencil to a cut won’t make it close up faster. Just a little would do. If you apply too much, it will only irritate your skin and nothing more.
  4. Never use hot or warm water to wet your styptic pencil; only use cold water and nothing else. 
  5. If possible, keep your styptic pencil sealed. Keeping it open in the air allows the aluminum sulfate to react to other elements, especially in a heated atmosphere.

Which is the better liquid styptic pencil or styptic powder pack?

This obviously depends on your choice, but in our opinion, a liquid styptic pencil is way better than styptic powder packs. This is because not only it’s a hassle to use a powder pack, but also, you don’t get any additional benefits that liquid styptic pencils provide.

What Chemicals are in a Styptic Pencil?

Generally, styptic pencils are based on off-styptic aluminum salts like aluminum sulfate, phosphate, or sodium aluminum sulfate. That being said, there can be other options like potassium, aloe vera, and more.  

Can I use my styptic pencil on pimples?

Yes, you can. Pimples, once popped, can ooze for hours. But you can stop that by putting a styptic pencil there. And don’t worry, there will be no side effects that affect your skin in any way.