Last Updated on

Best Solid Cologne

Finding a good solid cologne can be a tedious task, take a look at our top picks we are confident that you’ll find the perfect match right here!

Solid colognes can be a great alternative to their liquid counterpart. They are simple to use, provide a great aroma, and suit almost every skin type.

That being said, when you start looking for them, you’ll find multiple good choices. So, you’ll need to review all of them and find the ones that are perfect for you. It can be quite time-consuming.

Don’t worry because, in this article, we have done the work for you and reviewed the best solid colognes in the market. There’s also a buying guide attached which will help you to find the solid cologne that suits you perfectly.

So, thoroughly examine each section and you will be able to find the best solid cologne for yourself in no time!

5 Best Solid Cologne in 2022

Duke Cannon Supply Co. Solid Cologne, Bourbon - Charred Oak Barrel

Best Overall

If you are looking for a classic solid cologne then there aren’t many that can come close to this one from Duke Cannon Supply. It is efficient, offers a balanced scent, and comes with a budget-friendly price.

Scent Bourbon
Packaging Altoids tins
Consistency Medium
Longevity 4 to 12 hours
Value for Money Good value at 25.00$

This bourbon-scented solid cologne offers fragrance balance and long-lasting performance. For those who want to smell good but don’t want to overpower the area around them, this is a perfect choice.

You don’t have to worry about any synthetic or chemical ingredients as there is none. The cologne is made of natural & organic elements. So, apply them to any part of the skin without the fear of irritation or rashes.

Due to the medium consistency, it is very easy to apply without giving you any sticky feeling. The tin can is also great for travels and fits perfectly in pockets & briefcases.

So, overall, this is a good solid cologne that will serve its purpose perfectly without causing any hindrance.

Product Pros

  • A very good option for people on a low budget
  • The classic scent of bourbon is perfect for people who want to enjoy traditional wet shaves
  • Easy to use and have no sticky feeling
  • The tin has the perfect size to fit in any standard pocket size

Product Cons

  • The slide top is nice but not very secure
  • Gives a thick and goopy feel

Cremo Bergamot & Musk Travel-Friendly Solid Cologn

Best Value

There aren’t many solid colognes in the market that provides the amount of value for money that this one does. You get a strong performance at a cheap price so it’s a win in any way you look at it.

Scent Bergamot & Mask
Packaging Metal Tin
Consistency Medium - Balm
Longevity 1 hour
Value for Money Cheap price at 15.00$

The Cremo Bergamot & Musk Travel Friendly solid cologne is a mix of citrus notes and an amber musk finish. You will find the generated fragrance from this cologne soothing and comfortable.

While the duration is a bit low, during its effectiveness you will find the scent warping around you but not in an overpowering way. As it is TSA-approved you can use it without any concern whatsoever.

The metal carrier is small but holds a decent amount of cologne, making it a great choice for travel. Due to the medium concentration, you can easily apply it to your skin without facing problems.

The opener for the tin is also simple, just slide, and it will open up.

So, it offers good performance, and as it has a low price point than the rest, it is arguably one of the cheapest but well-performing solid cologne in the market.

Product Pros

  • A balanced fragrance, that doesn’t smell too strong when applied
  • Extremely budget friendly
  • Offers a durable packaging
  • Simple applying procedure so it won’t get messy

Product Cons

  • Very short longevity
  • Requires to reapply several times
  • Case suffers from rusting
  • A large packaging for a very small tin of cologne

Diptyque Philosykos Solid Perfume

Best Design

Diptyque has been around for the past few decades. And the Philosykos solid cologne is one of their trademark products that has made its name due to the positive performance it has shown throughout the years.

Scent Philosykos
Packaging Metal
Consistency Medium - Balm
Longevity 4 to 12 hours
Value for Money Pricey at 79.99$

Launched in 1996, this solid cologne offers a woody aromatic scent that is not too overpowering nor too dim. It is just perfect. The effectiveness of the cologne lasts for a long while, almost 12 hours.

But that is not even the most exciting part. The solid cologne comes with a beautifully built  metal can that is a work of art. It can easily fit into any pocket or purse.

The application process is also simple due to the medium consistency of the cologne. You won’t feel any stickiness not see any leftover residue after using this product.

It is a solid choice for anyone who is looking for something elegant with a good performance and carrying option.

Product Pros

  • A beautiful yet simple scent that is refreshing but not overpowering
  • Easy to keep in a purse or pocket
  • No soapiness in the fragrance
  • Offers a very good longevity

Product Cons

  • Has a bit of a damp grassy smell
  • Very expensive compared to other solid colognes
  • When it’s humid, handling it can be quite overwhelming

Outlaw Blazing Saddles - Hard Cologne for Men & Women

Best Usability

When it comes to scent and usability, the Blazing Saddle from Outlaw is arguably the best solid cologne out there. You get multiple natural scent combinations with a great result with this product.

Scent Leather, Gunpowder, Sagebrush, Sandalwood
Packaging Metal Tin
Consistency Hard - Wax
Longevity 4 to 12 hours
Value for Money Good value at 25$

If you are inspired by the legends of the west then this product from Outlaw will be perfect for you. Based on the classic scent of the west this wax-based cologne is made out of natural ingredients like leather, sage, sandalwood, and more.

It is completely aluminum-free and comes with a good price tag. The design of the can is eye-catching. And the best part, the cologne lasts for a long time while maintaining a balanced comforting scent during the time its duration.

You can easily put the can in your pocket or purse. If you prefer the cowboy style of keeping it in the shoe, then you can even do that, but it can be irritating if you do that.

Overall, it’s a great product, especially for the fans of the western cowboy lifestyle.

Product Pros

  • Low budget-friendly pricing
  • Eye-catching presentation & packaging that looks good on your shelf
  • Has a balanced scent that is not overpowering to sensitive noses
  • Good longevity lasts around at least 5 hours

Product Cons

  • Short-lived scent
  • The wax is too solid
  • Leaves oil residue on clothes sometimes

Mr. Gladstone Solid Cologne

Best Travel

If you want the best travel solid cologne with optimal performance, then this is the one you have been looking for. This product is small, effective, and comes with a very low price tag.

Scent Cathay, Trevellin, Vieux Port
Packaging Metal Tin
Consistency Hard - Wax
Longevity 2 to 4 hours
Value for Money Good value at 19$

The Mr. Gladstone solid cologne offers a balanced, not too overpowering scent from the mix of shea butter, coconut oil, almond oil, and mango butter. There is a mix of artificial and natural ingredients,

But don’t let that bother you, as this product works exceptionally well with sensitive skins. It lasts for a decent amount of time, although the scent will start to drop as time passes on.

Due to the small form factor of the meta tin, you can carry it anywhere you want. It should fit into all types of pockets and bags. And the performance remains the same no matter the condition the cologne is in.

So, if you travel quite a lot and want a solid cologne that will provide you quality service during your outings, then we highly recommend this cologne from Mr. Gladstone. Trust us, you won’t be disappointed.

Product Pros

  • Good scent, not too strong so it won’t make your nose twitch
  • Perfect for on-the-go application
  • Small and fits easily in the pocket
  • Decent option for low-budget spenders

Product Cons

  • Scent starts to drop after an hour
  • Gets melted easily in summer

What to Consider When Choosing Solid Cologne for Yourself

You can’t just go ahead and pick a solid cologne without checking certain factors. Otherwise, you will end up with a cologne that doesn’t perform well and ends up irritating you instead of making you feel good.

To avoid this situation, here are the factors that you should consider when choosing a solid cologne for yourself:

Scent

The most important part of any cologne is the scent. And if you don’t like the scent then you shouldn’t even bother to look into any other factors, that cologne is not for you.

Whether a scent is good or bad completely depends on the person experiencing it. It is one of those subjective questions that can never really be answered by a single person. One might like the scent of a certain solid cologne, while another might hate it.

That being said, there are certain things that you can check on the scent of solid colognes.

Type of Scent

Firstly, find out what sort of scent you want from your cologne. There are different types of aromas that you can opt for. From the floral scent to various fruits, there is a lot to consider in this section.

Strength of Scent

Once you are done with selecting the type of scent you want, move forward to how strong you want the impact to be. You can go with a low-key option, or you can pick a super strong scent.

We recommend that you go with a medium or standard amount of strength. Because overpowering aroma isn’t something, most people are fond of. At the same time, if the strength is too low, then you might even recognize it afterward. Therefore, the middle ground is the best option, in our opinion.

How It Reacts to Your Body

Another factor regarding scent is how it reacts with your body. For example, if the scent starts to create a putrid aroma when it comes into contact with your sweat, then you should consider switching to a different option.

This also applies to the environment you will be staying in too. As solid colognes require you to apply it from time to time, if you are in an environment where other scents are present, then you might end up with a horrible aroma instead of a pleasing one.

So, make sure you keep all of these considerations in mind when choosing the scent for your solid cologne.

Base Material

Next, you need to consider the base material of the solid cologne. This type of cologne requires only one base material, and that is natural wax.

Now there are a lot of different types of natural wax out there, but the most popular and highly used are beeswax and shea butter. Petroleum jelly can also be a viable option.

But we suggest that you pick up a solid cologne that has either beeswax or shea butter as the base material.

When checking the base material, you should also look into additional materials used in the cologne as well. There shouldn’t be any harmful chemicals involved. The alcohol amount will be significantly low compared to liquid colognes too.

Packaging

One of the biggest advantages of solid colognes over their liquid counterpart is that they much safer and more comfortable to travel with.

Fortunately, there is no chance of leaking or evaporating. But this benefit largely depends on the packaging the solid colognes come with. That’s why you should examine the packaging or the container of the cologne before you make your purchase.

The container should be durable but not too heavy. It should have easy access because you will need to open it from time to time to apply the cologne to your skin. Metal tin containers are the best in this case.

As for the size of the container, it heavily depends on your personal preference. Generally, we recommend that you go with a small-sized packaging as it will be easier to travel with.

But if you don’t want to buy a new one anytime soon, then you can go with a bigger size option. 

Consistency

The consistency of the solid cologne is something people often forget and only remember when they start to use the product regularly.

Generally, you should opt for something similar to a butter-like consistency, you need to ensure that it is easy to spread with minimal effort. But that doesn’t mean your solid cologne will melt when you touch it.

Now, if you are not comfortable with the buttery feel, then you can go for a bit denser spread but don’t go completely dense.

Avoid dense consistency at any cost because this solid cologne can get hard as a rock and won’t spread easily. You shouldn’t have to use your full force just to use your cologne now, do you?

Weight

You should also keep an eye out for the total weight of the solid cologne. This is because if you want your cologne’s smell to last, then you will have to reapply it from time to time, and with a heavy-weighted cologne, that isn’t easy.

While that is true, if you are confident that you are fine with the extra weight, then you go opt for a heavier solid cologne.

Longevity

Compared to liquid cologne, solid cologne offers a low-lasting time. But you can easily apply it back and continue. That being said, you shouldn’t have to do that too often throughout the day. Maybe three or four times at max.

Therefore, ensure that the solid cologne you are picking offers good longevity. From our point of view somewhere between two to ten hours is the best choice. The higher the better in this case.

Companies will claim that their product lasts longer than their competition, so make sure you check reviews from actual buyers before estimating the longevity of solid cologne.

Overall Pricing

Last but not the least, the pricing of the solid cologne should be reasonable. You shouldn’t have to pay a fortune just to get a good product. Make sure that you are getting the right amount for the money you are paying.

We recommend that you don’t go over 80 USD for a solid cologne. But there are exceptions to this estimation. Therefore, if you are paying a high price to ensure that the cologne comes with additional features to match up to that cost.

And there you have it. These are the factors that you should consider before selecting a solid cologne as the best suit for yourself.

Tips for Buying and Using Solid Cologne

When it comes to buying solid colognes, there are a few tips that can help you in the long run and make sure that you are getting the best possible option for yourself. These tips are:

Physical Testing Is Better

While we all rely on online shopping, it is better, especially if this is your first time to go to a physical store and test the colognes yourself first. Once you learn what works for you, then you can go ahead and proceed to online shopping sessions.

This is mainly because you won’t have much idea of how the fragrance of the cologne is if you don’t have any first-hand experience before.

Let the Cologne Set on Your Skin

You shouldn’t decide on a solid cologne just by initial testing at first glance. Let the cologne set on your skin for at least half an hour. This way, if there is any negative reaction, you will be able to identify it right away.

And if there is one, then you should disregard that solid cologne no matter how good the scent or feeling was. Because if it is harmful to your skin, then it is not the one for you.

Normally, stores don’t take back a cologne after it has been used, even if once. So, this way, you won’t have to be stuck with a product that isn’t compatible with your skin.

Purchase from Branded or Reliable Source

This applies to both in-store and online purchases. Branded products are verified by many, their pros and cons are available to the public, and they have been tested by health authorities before coming out to the market.

This isn’t true for unbranded solid colognes. And there are a lot of cheap knock-offs of popular brands. So, don’t go ahead and buy them just to save a few bucks.

Therefore, even if you have to pay a bit more. It is safer to buy your solid colognes from trusted and verified sources.

Learn How to Use It Properly

Solid colognes have a different usage style than liquid colognes or fragrant soaps in that regard. You need to rub it on the pulse points on your skin gently. Places like the neck or wrist are some examples.

Now, you might have to use a bit of force when you are rubbing on the solid cologne or putting them on your skin.

It is completely natural for the cologne to be a bit strong; you shouldn’t apply any warm or cold water whatsoever. Just use the friction generated from your fingers, nothing else.

Does solid cologne last for an entire day?

No, most solid colognes don’t last for more than twelve hours. And even if they do the power of the scent is almost close to zero.

Besides, solid colognes aren’t meant to be used that way anyway. You should apply them to your skin at least twice a day if you want to have its fragrance.

Will the solid cologne in my pocket melt in summer?

No, unless you are going through extreme heat, there isn’t any possibility that the cologne will melt.

Is solid cologne good for sensitive skin?

Yes, solid colognes have a positive impact on sensitive skin. This is due to the fact that, unlike liquid colognes, they have a lower alcohol percentage, and the wax base is also soothing on the skin.

Is spray cologne better than solid cologne?

Both spray and solid colognes have the same smell. But if you want a cologne that is stronger and smells longer, then you might be better off with a spray cologne.