Last Updated on

Best Shaving Soap

Searching for the best shaving soap for your skin? Then look no further; we have gathered the list of the best shaving soaps right here!

Shaving is a crucial part of our life unless we want our bodily & facial hair to grow wild, making us look like cavemen. But finding the best shaving soap for yourself can be quite difficult because there are a lot of factors that come into play.

And just picking one from the best men’s shaving soaps list isn’t going to solve your problem. Don’t worry, because we have got you covered.

Our team has gone through different variations of shaving soaps and picked the ones that fit the category of every type of buyer. We have also provided an in-depth buying guide that will help you to find the perfect shave soap for yourself.

5 Best Shaving Soap in 2022

Viking Revolution Shaving Soap for Men

Best Overall

There are only a few soaps that can rival the quality that the Viking Revolution shaving soap can bring. This has arguably the best overall features you can get in the market.

Base Glycerin
Skin Type All
Scent Pine, Sandalwood, Cedar, Sage, Bay Rum
Weight  2.5 oz

For the smoothest wet shaves, there is almost no competition for this shaving soap. The pricing is good, along with the scents that it brings. Not many shaving soaps out there can offer more than two scent types, but with the Viking Revolution, you will get more than four.

The puck also lasts for quite a long time, so you don’t have to worry about running out any time soon. And getting four soaps as a package deal is quite rare in the market!

Product Pros

  • Smells great that will leave you feeling refreshed
  • Amazing price for people on a budget
  • Variety of scents that appeal to a large crowd
  • Great customer support

Product Cons

  • Softer than other soaps
  • Smaller compared to other soaps

Lather & Wood Shaving Soap

Best Scent

This soap is known for its magnificent scent and long-lasting capability. For those who want to enjoy their shaving session, it is one of the best choices.

Base Tallow
Skin Type All
Scent Clean, Crisp, Barbershop scent
Weight 4.7 oz

If you are looking for longevity, then this is the soap for you. All of these soaps are handcrafted and made in small batches to ensure quality and effectiveness.

The scent of this soap will provide a barbershop feel that you just can’t have more of. It is also great for sensitive skin as it offers shea butter as one of its ingredients.

With three different variations, this shaving soap rivals industry giants like the Taylor of Old Bond Street and others.

Product Pros

  • Amazing tallow lather that does not alter the pH of your skin
  • Variety of scents that smell amazing
  • Long-lasting soap to give a smooth shaving experience
  • Stiffness doesn’t deteriorate over time

Product Cons

  • Have to scoop it out of the tin
  • Some users have found the amount to be a little low

Gentleman Jon Sandalwood Shave Soap

B00XX69OA0

For the best value in the market, no other product even comes close to what Gentleman Jon Sandalwood Shave Soap can bring. With good quality and low pricing, this is arguably one of the best shaving soaps you can get your hand on.

Base Glycerin
Skin Type All
Scent Sandwood
Weight 2.25 oz

If you are looking for rich, slick & creamy leathering, then the Gentleman Jon Sandalwood Shave Soap is the best out there. The puck will last for a long time, and the fresh scent of the barbershop will make each of your shaving sessions bliss.

And you are getting all of these without paying less than what others have to offer.

Product Pros

  • Large 2.25 Oz size that would last a long time
  • Has the magnificent scent of sandalwood
  • Offers a slick lather without having to work it too much
  • A long-lasting puck that is all natural and handles shaving well

Product Cons

  • The scent doesn't last
  • Doesn't moisturize the face

Henry Cavendish Himalaya Shaving Soap

Best for Sensitive Skin

A perfect option for people with sensitive skin, this soap will not only provide a comfortable shave but also improve the smoothness of the skin.

Base Glycerin
Skin Type All
Scent Shea Butter
Weight 3.8 oz

This American-made soap offers many benefits for its users with standard pricing.

You will get good lathering, which will allow your razer to move freely without worrying about getting a potential cut.

The addition of shea and inclusion of green tea makes this soap more effective than many other face creams out there.

Also, the cream is highly adored by females as it leaves the skin moisturized and smooth once you are done.

That’s why many refer to this soap as the best shaving soap for sensitive skin.

Product Pros

  • Great for ladies with the shea addition
  • All natural ingredients that are not harsh on your skin
  • Thick smooth lathering that will moisturize your skin
  • The hint of green tea in the shea butter scent is amazing and cool on your skin

Product Cons

  • Small diameter puck
  • Somewhat dry foam

Sir Hare Shaving soap

Best Usability

For a protective and harmonious shaving experience, there are only a few soaps out there that can last long as Sir Hare shaving soaps. For enthusiasts, this is a must-purchase!

Base Tallow
Skin Type All
Scent Fresh and Clean with hints of Bergamot, Oakmoss, Sandalwood, and Cedarwood
Weight 6.4 oz

One of the most long-lasting shaving soaps out there, Sir Hare also offers an array of different scent options for you to choose from. And all of them are exclusive and give you the fresh and natural feel that you expect.

That’s not all, you will encounter zero irritation with this shaving soap, and 4 ounces of this product will ensure that you keep enjoying your grooming session without any worries.

Every soap is handmade and retains its quality in every batch. And it is effective for all skin types. So, you don’t have to worry about that at all.

Product Pros

  • Good tasteful fragrances available in an array of choices
  • Protective and cushy lather that won’t irritate your skin
  • Last for more than 100 shave
  • Handmade soaps made with high-quality ingredients

Product Cons

  • Some people had a hard time with the lather

Rocky Mountain Shaving Soap

Best Thick Lathering

The Rocky Mountain Shaving Soap offers one of the best latherings and gives you the feeling of a barbershop at home. This is perfect for those with sensitive skin.

Base Water
Skin Type All
Scent Classic Barbershop Scent
Weight 5 oz

For a perfect thick lathering, you will find no better option than Rocky Mountain Shaving Soap. This product is being used by more than two thousand men every day, and this is because they offer what they say.

If you ever want the barbershop shave feeling then this soap can certainly produce that.  They are made in small portions so that all of them contain the maximum amount of quality & freshness.

The application is also versatile. You can either go with a brush or use your hands instead.

Product Pros

  • Easily get thick lather in a small time
  • Made in small batches to maintain its premium quality
  • Long-lasting and will give you the best value
  • Handmade soap with great finesse

Product Cons

  • Might be slightly expensive

The Blades Grim – Luxury Shave Soap

Best Natural

There are only a few all-natural shaving soaps that can compare their quality with The Blades Grim, but even then, this soap will come out on top!

Base Glycerin
Skin Type All
Scent  Smolder, Cannisters
Weight 4 oz

A big complaint for many popular shaving soaps is that there are too many harmful chemicals being used to provide the features.

But that is not the case when it comes to the Blades Grim, as this shaving soap is made from all-natural ingredients, and there is no hint of any harmful chemicals.

This makes this soap the perfect candidate for people with sensitive skin as they don’t have to worry about any chemical issues causing their skin harm.

The 4-ounce puck is also quite long-lasting than most others. Therefore, making it the perfect choice if you are looking for a soap that will serve you for a good amount of time.

Along with that, you will get a screw top lid, and this helps you to escape the need of having a shaving bowl to keep the soap in.

That being said, it is always recommended that you keep your soap in a proper soap bowl.

Product Pros

  • All-natural ingredients that are suitable for sensitive skin
  • Thick lathering that comes up quickly and evenly
  • Long-lasting and would serve you for about a year
  • Screw top lid with its packing is appealing and robust

Product Cons

  • Too much water and you have to start over
  • Costlier than other soaps

What to Consider When Choosing Shaving Soaps for Yourself

Now, a lot of factors you need to check before deciding on a soap for yourself.

If you ignore them, you will end up with a shave soap that doesn’t fit your preferences and hate the product afterward.

But don’t worry, because the important facts that you have to consider before choosing shaving soaps for yourself are given below:

Pick A Soap for Suiting Your Skin

The reason why there are different opinions on the best shaving creams is due to the fact that one soap might be best for a specific skin type while the others may not.

Now, understanding skin types can be a bit difficult at first. That’s why we suggest that you consult a professional regarding different skin types and find out yours. This way, you will be able to find the best shaving soap for yourself without any problem. 

Type of Shaving Soap

The first thing that you need to consider when purchasing any shave soap is the type.

There are quite a few variants of shaving soaps in the market. But if you check the build quality, materials & usage, you can divide them into three versions:

1.     Triple Pressed Shave Soap

2.     Creamy or Morbid Shave Soap

3.     Stick or Bar Shave Soap

Triple Milled Or Pressed Shave Soap

The triple milled or more commonly known as triple pressed shaving soaps are very popular among professionals and a highly recommended product for anyone who wants to get started with wet shaving.

This is because this type of shaving soap inherits the true meaning of shaving by being homogenous, finely grained & highly conservative of water of any sort.

Therefore, you will be able to get thick lather & a good amount of foam from a tiny amount of soap. The soap’s texture is also highly preserved, so you can be assured of the fact that the quality and rich lather won’t deteriorate over time, and you can use it for a long period.

One thing that you should remember about these soaps is that you should always use a strong, stiff brush to get a good creamy lather.

A good example of triple-pressed shave soap is proraso shaving soap.

Creamy Or Morbid Shave soap

The feature that differentiates these types of soap from the rest is that they come with a bigger water content compared to other shaving soap variants. This means creamy or morbid shaving contains more glycerin or oil than the rest.

For this reason, they are a good alternative for perfumes which is why many often categorize them as scented soap.

And there are quite a few options depending on the type of glycerin-based soap.

From menthol scent to the fresh scent of flowers, these fragranced soaps have a lot of options for the customers to choose from. And the most exciting prospect of this is that they don’t cost much.

Morbid shaving soaps are available for an economical price. A good example of this type of soap will be the Taylor of Old Bond Street.

Stick or Bar Shave Soap

Finally, there are stick or bar shaving soap variants.

They share similar qualities with the triple-pressed shaving soaps, but for giving a good long-lasting lather, they have a higher water composition than the triple-pressed ones.

This allows you to use this soap directly on your face without needing the help of a shaving brush. But that being said, you can go with a brush first, but in that case, you will have to use a stiff one.

How you shave with this type of soap is a raging topic in the shaving community.

You can go with the standard west coast shaving style by directly applying your soap and then going with a straight razor, or you can try different lathering techniques and figure out which one is the best for you.

This also depends on your other grooming products and your skills with a razor blade. That being said, you can be assured of the fact that you will get a great lather and pleasant shaving experience with this type of soap.

There are also other options that you can find in the market, like Italian shave soaps or shaving foams, but all of them fall under the mentioned three types.

Glycerin & Fat Content

In order to find a great shaving soap for yourself, you need to look into the amount of glycerin and fat in the soap that you are picking, as they are the base ingredients. And the better the amount & quality of these contents, the better the lather will be.

Both glycerin and fat are important as they define how good a shaving soap actually is.

This also answers why you should pick it over other options like shaving creams.

Glycerin acts as the humectant, and it ensures that the skin is hydrated, which eases the beard making the skin smooth and moisturized. There are multiple ingredients from which glycerin is obtained, but mostly they are found in vegetable or natural oils like castor oil or coconut oil.

On the other hand, the fat content on the soap allows you to use your razor blade smoothly across your face without facing any issues. It also keeps the skin hydrated and acts as a lubricant that protects you from razor burn.

The fat contained can also be obtained from different sources like wool fat, shea butter, mango butter, coconut butter, and more.

Finding the shave soap’s base is very important if you want to have the best shaving soap at your disposal. Because if you have sensitive skin, you can’t just put any type of fat or glycerin in your skin.

Complete Ingredients List

You need to look into all the ingredients of your shaving soap if you want to have the perfect shave. A quality soap should have all the ingredients that help your skin to be smooth and get a good lather.

Although you should check on all the ingredients in your soap, one ingredient that you need to take a deeper look at, apart from glycerin and fat, is the tallow base.

While one might argue over the fact that tallow is a form of fat, it is animal fat, not plant-based.

Also, tallow-based shaving soap has its pros and cons depending on the type of skin it is being applied to.

So keep an eye out for tallow when you are checking the ingredients. Additional ingredients like green tea, menthol, and other chemicals should also be considered.

Scent Or Aroma

Now shaving soap is nothing without its aroma. If you are looking for a good shave soap that will give you an irritation-free shave, then you need a soap that provides you with the scent that you like.

One of the biggest reasons why many go for soaps over shaving creams is the aroma.

A shaving cream can’t provide the comfortable scent that a soap can. That’s why when picking up soap, always check how it scents.

Also, stay far away from alcohol-infused soaps as most of the time, they will irritate your skin during wet shaving.

While that’s true, if you have very sensitive skin and prefer wet shaving, then going with a scented soap is not the best option. Otherwise, you might end up with negative effects at the price of smelling good during your shave.

You should also decide upon how strong and lasting you want the scent to be. Some prefer to have the aroma only during shaving, while some want it to last even after they are done.

So, find out the duration of the scent before you finalize the soap. This is also true for picking a shaving cream or foam.

Ease of Use & Usability

This is a common factor, but you want a comfortable experience with your shaving soap, not the other way around.

You should aim to pick a soap that doesn’t require you to opt for safety razors.

A soap that ensures that you will have a clean & close shave with an amazing lather. The soap should also be able to last for at least a year without completely being depleted. But this might vary depending on the type of beard, growth & thickness you have.

Overall Price

Another factor that you should keep in mind is the price. A grooming soap isn’t very pricey, and most of the time, shaving cream is costlier than soap.

That said, if you are looking for specific ingredients for shaving soap, the price might be a little high, but it should never be over three-figure numbers.

And there you have it; these are all the factors you need to decide upon before picking up a shaving soap that you think is the best for you.

Tips for Buying And Using A Shave Soap & Shaving Brush

There are a few tips and tricks that you should use if you want to get the most out of your shaving soap. And they are:

Understand The Difference Between Shaving Cream & Soap

First, you need to understand that you are using a block of soap and not shaving cream.

So, you can’t apply the soap the way you apply wet shaving cream on your face.

The first big difference between the two is that a bar of soap will be quite firm compared to shaving creams. This will affect how you shave.

For wet shaving, you will have to use a decent amount of water on a soap compared to shaving cream.

Getting a good lather can be a bit difficult at first with shaving soaps.

But at the same time, once you master it, no cream can provide the lather that a creamy shaving soap can.

The texture will also be different between shaving cream and soap.

That’s why you might have to change the shaving ingredients that you used earlier.

Overall, while you might not notice it at first glance, there is quite a big difference between shaving cream and soap.

And without understanding them properly, you won’t be able to enjoy or transit into shaving soaps at all 

Get The Necessary Tools

You won’t be able to get the creamy lather for your sensitive skin just by getting a lather shaving soap. No, you will need to get quite a few tools for the perfect grooming experience.

The tools that you will be needing are the following:

Shaving Brush

You can’t get a good lather if you don’t have the perfect shaving brush with your shaving soap. And there are quite a few options out there.

But the type of shave brush you will have to pick will largely depend on what type of soap you are using.

Generally, for most cases, picking a stiff & strong shaving brush is the best option, especially if you use a semi-soft soap. 

Shaving Bowl

If you want to get the slick lather during your shaving sessions, then you can’t keep your soap wide open on the basin or overflowed with water.

That’s why you need your own shaving bowl to keep your soap mess free & germ-free at the same time.

The type of shaving bowl depends on materials, and while you can go with a plastic bowl, we recommend going with stainless steel ones if possible.

This is especially true if you are going with a hard puck soap for your preferable shaving soap.

Sometimes you might also get a bowl for free, like the ones you get after purchasing an Arko shaving soap.

Towels

Believe it or not, towels play a significant role in a perfect shave. If you have sensitive skin, then using a hot towel to prepare your skin before you start shaving is a good way to ensure that you don’t suffer from any issues. 

Safety Razors

While you should always use share razors for shaving, it is essential that you have at least one safety razor at your disposal.

Sometimes you might not feel it, or you can be sick; in such situations, a safety razor will become exceptionally handy and will help you to cut through the thick lather of your shaving soap with ease.

A safety razor is also a must for sensitive skin until you find the right razor and the perfect soap.

Master Lathering Techniques

If you want to have a clean shave, then you need to master how to lather properly. There are quite a few lathering techniques, so pick one and perfect that one first, and then move on to another.

Continue this until you find the right lathering technique for yourself.

Brand Awareness is Important

To find the best shaving soaps in the market, you should always prioritize known brands over unknown ones. This is due to the fact that they are well known not only because of their marketing team but also because they have pleased their clients.

So, popular brands like the Taylor of Old Bond Street or Sandalwood shaving soap should not be ignored as these products can provide the rich lather you have been searching for. Just give one of them a try.

What is the difference between shaving soaps & normal soaps?

The main difference between a standard and shaving soap is in the produced leather.

With a standard or normal soap, you will get a thin layer which is great for cleaning dirt.

But with shave soaps, you get thicker & denser lathering offering better protection compared to the ones you will get from a normal soap.

Is coconut oil shaving soap good for my sensitive skin?

Coconut oil-embedded shave soaps are highly recommended for people with sensitive skin. This is because they offer a high moisturization which offers a soothing effect and allows us to have a clean and smooth shave.

That’s why they are a perfect recommendation for those who have dry skin or dehydration issues.

On the other hand, if you have oily skin or it stays way too moisturized, then coconut oil will be bad. In this case, you should avoid shaving soaps that offer this ingredient.

My shaving soaps always get wet; how can I fix this?

Well, if you are having this problem, then the issue lies with you picking a shaving soap with low water absorption, or you are not keeping your soap in a soap bowl or in a place where it is drowning in water.

Also, check if your soap comes with wool fat as an ingredient. Wool fat generally increases the water resistance of shaving soap, making it more waterproof. So, if your soap doesn’t have that, then get one that does.

Which ingredients should I look for if I want to increase the thickness of my soap’s lathering?

There are a lot of factors that come into play when increasing the thickness of a soap’s lathering. But generally, if you go with a shaving soap that comes with shea butter along with vitamin E, you will get a higher thickness compared to the competition.